Mythic Quest Season 4 Review: Episodes 1-9
Mythic Quest's two-part season 4 premiere streams on Apple TV+ beginning Wednesday, January 29, with new episodes debuting weekly through March 26.
After lengthy hiatuses, Severance and Mythic Quest return to the office this month. But that’s not the only thing the sci-fi thriller and the workplace comedy have in common: Both Apple TV+ shows are equally invested in exploring personal and professional boundaries (or lack thereof). In its fourth season, the MQ team still struggles to separate home and office, but Poppy Liu (Charlotte Nicdao) embraces a “work work life balance.” That phrase, with its purposeful repetition, hits on the relatable and absurd qualities of this workaholic environment – even after all this time away, Mythic Quest remains sharp and incisive in depicting the world of video-game development. No cheat code is available to prevent Poppy from getting too entangled with creative partner Ian Grimm (Rob McElhenney), and the duo remains the series' driving force. Introducing another man into Poppy’s life (an artist called Storm, played by Chase Yi) upsets the equilibrium, giving the season a different energy from previous years. Disrupting the status quo ensures Mythic Quest isn’t repeating itself, even if Poppy and Ian have returned to the MQ fold after their stint running GrimPop Studios.
While Poppy and Ian’s rollercoaster partnership brilliantly anchors season 4, creators McElhenney, Megan Ganz, and Charlie Day (the last of whom guest stars this season) have always understood that the strength of Mythic Quest lies in its ensemble. Everyone is back in the same place, yet their relationships are more fractured than ever. Dana’s (Imani Hakim) game within Playpen is driving huge numbers, and still, MQ gets the lion’s share of the revenue it generates. The goalposts of success continue to move, and she tries to hit the elusive sweet spot between artistic fulfillment and earning her worth. Her girlfriend, Rachel (Ashly Burch), is the head of monetization for MQ, and there’s no way to predict how the pair will navigate that conflict of interest. Jo (Jessie Ennis) and Brad (Danny Pudi) are part of Dana’s team, and they immediately add a level of intensity when anyone tries to enter Dana’s office. She might not have financial power, but Dana’s support system terrifies David (David Hornsby).
This trio isn’t the only winning dynamic in the mix. Season 4 soars when it pairs Rachel and David for a congressional hearing; the same goes for when most of the crew comes together for an Ethics Committee meeting. There’s no weak link here, but with a cast this big and so many ongoing threads to manage, some moments from earlier in the season fizzle too quickly. The gang gets a new hot potato to toss around in the form of generative AI, but through the first nine episodes of season 4, that topic – with its profound implications for the characters onscreen, the actors playing them, the writers’ room, heck everyone involved with the production of Mythic Quest – provides some brief laughs but not much else. Witnessing a pro-AI Ian come up against a flawed system only left me wanting more.
Other ebbs and flows in the video game industry still provide a lot of humor and tension. Giving the users power turns Playpen’s kid-friendly platform into a haven of animated smut, delivering a bounty of visual gags. Though the platform still generates interest, an overall dip in sales in a post-lockdown world leads to a recurring gag in which David pines for the financially plum heyday of the pandemic. His people-pleasing attempts often backfire, yet his lack of spine, tone-deaf reasoning, and constant siding with corporate ensure you don’t feel too bad for him. The more exasperated he becomes, the funnier Hornsby gets.
Playing with the formula keeps MQ’s dysfunctions fresh. (Another feather of invention and innovation in the series’ cap: The forthcoming four-part spinoff Side Quest, which debuts the same day as the fourth-season finale.) Season 4 doesn’t skip the Mythic Quest tradition of a one-off detour from the main story, and though it doesn’t hit the heights of season 1’s “A Dark Quiet Death,” the episode’s focus creatively fits the “setting boundaries” theme. This episode taps into a corner of the industry that continues to grow, and the sitcom maintains its funny and silly streak while delving into (but not getting bogged down by) real life issues.
Another standout episode takes place outside the offices, with the entire team (plus Storm) receiving an invitation to a secluded location for a murder mystery. Playing games is central to the MQ business model, but in this case, some good old-fashioned sleuthing taps into the personal stakes that make Mythic Quest so appealing. In any creative field, you have to move forward and reinvent; this episode both demonstrates and achieves this in the way storylines advance and characters evolve. A whodunnit in the vein of Mafia (or even Traitors) provides a familiar enough backdrop to convince each of the participants that they a) know the game inside and out, and b) can win. Costume designer Sabrina Rosen nails the Agatha Christie-leaning wardrobe required for the episode, and the entire ensemble flourishes in this setting. The episode, directed by Ganz (who co-wrote it with Humphrey Ker), gets to the heart of the nuanced relationships that have been building since season 1, while also throwing thorny and sweet surprises into the mix.
Poppy and Ian have survived plenty of storms in the past, but a new one is brewing thanks to her love life. (Yes, there are plenty of puns on Poppy’s new boyfriend’s name, and no, I couldn’t resist getting in the mix.) The platonic creative partners exist outside of a will-they/won’t-they situation, yet Storm introduces all the ingredients of a classic love triangle. Ian’s jealousy isn’t informed by romantic attraction, but his reaction to Poppy finding something fulfilling beyond her career makes the duo’s journey fascinating. If work is no longer all Poppy thinks about, then where does that leave Ian? They have weathered myriad conflicts (including the failure of GrimPop last season), and creating the next thing is the glue that sticks them together. However, Poppy finding a new source of happiness – and even inspiration – has the potential to break them apart.
The previous victories and ruptures fueled by ego, expectation, and talent make this all work. Nicdao gets to tap into new and old insecurities and is equally convincing across a spectrum of emotions that make her the MVP of the season. And her comedic timing here is next level. Poppy is still a hot mess, which further adds to the comedy and this arc is a brilliant showcase for Nicdao (who also directs this season).
At the helm, McElhenney is dependable in showing Ian’s endless arrogance and vulnerabilities. Change is hard, and while Ian resorts to old tactics, Mythic Quest’s depiction of evolving priorities ensures this season feels as fresh as ever, immediately pulling us back into this world after a prolonged absence and proving it is far from game over.